X-Men Don’t Thank Just Dad for the Mutations

Where do those mutants come from anyway?

I’ve recently seen X-Men First Class, and what a trip of a movie. When wondering about who to credit for super-genes and super-powers, we would normally turn to good old Dad. It was long thought that mutations were more likely to be inherited from men. Maybe we would credit Mom, but probably only if it were a good mutation. New data from the team at University of Montreal just out this June show it might have been Dad, it might have been Mom, but chances are much better that it was really the environment. In fact it’s looking like 30:1 it was probably the environment.

The new study shows that by sequencing the human genome DNA of parents and their sons or daughters,  about 50 mutations were inherited. In contrast, over 1500 were created in the cells as they grew later. Called “somatic” mutations, this means changes in the genes that happen as the body grows, but were not, and are not inherited.

This lends credibility to one of the central themes in X-Men, that radiation forces will create mutations (rather than simply inheriting them from Dad or Mom). After seeing the human genome sequencing results, researchers understand even more clearly that mutation rates are very uneven. For experimental work in the lab, mutations are usually created by geneticists with toxins or radiation to speed things up a bit. It might sound odd, but that’s what we do.

An interesting trait in corn I’ve worked with in my genetics research, was one my mentor Barbara McClintock called X-factor. It was inherited, and sped up mutations so dramatically that each generation many of the seedlings would not even survive. I thought this was a much better route than working with toxins or radiation in the lab to create new mutants. As far as I can see, toxins and radiation are things to avoid in the lab as well as in life and our environment. The location of the X-factor trait was continuously changing, and it was highly unstable much like the transposons or jumping genes. Transposons are also inherited, and highly mutagenic and create much of the beautiful color variation seen on the surface of multicolored, spotted and striped corn kernels. While I was able to work with the transposon strains of corn for a few years, the X-factor plants did not survive. The mutation burden was really too high.

The genes for X-factor and for transposons are fascinating. And if we ever have an X-Women movie, I’m going to suggest they give up on the radiation bit and just go for the inherited, super mutating gene, X-factor.

To read the original article on human mutation posted online at Nature Genetics June 12:

Variation in genome-wide mutation rates within and between human families.

the 1000 Genomes Project, Conrad DF, Keebler JE, Depristo MA, Lindsay SJ, Zhang Y, Casals F, Idaghdour Y, Hartl CL, Torroja C, Garimella KV, Zilversmit M, Cartwright R, Rouleau GA, Daly M, Stone EA, Hurles ME, Awadalla P.

Nat Genet. 2011 Jun 12. doi: 10.1038/ng.862. [Epub ahead of print]

3 responses to “X-Men Don’t Thank Just Dad for the Mutations”

  1. I just saw that movie too. Knowing the human genome, I suppose we could mutate one of those skills, but it’d probably be a passive gene so would immediately die out.

    Sad, isn’t it?


  2. Cynthia you raise a concern I share, and many others I’m sure. The radiation will surely affect all the creatures; plants, animals, people and their progeny. And outside of science fiction, most of the mutations are difficult to bear not for making us stronger but weaker. Thank you for sharing your reactions here at the blog.


  3. When I first began reading I thought you were going to discuss mtDNA (moms vs dads) but you took it in a completely different direction.

    Frightening to contemplate what effect all the radiation released into the population of Japan will have.

    Interesting post, Jennifer.



Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: